A reasonable accommodation request deserves a conversation, even when the employer cannot grant the exact request. In EEOC v. Buc-ee’s, a federal lawsuit filed in Texas, the EEOC alleges that a retail chain denied a cashier a chair without ever engaging in the interactive process, then terminated him when he could not return to work. ComPsych ADA coach Steve Chaifetz walks through the case below.
What happened
Dale Witt worked as a cashier at Buc-ee’s. In October 2024, he was diagnosed with myasthenia gravis, a chronic neuromuscular condition that limits his ability to stand for long periods. Based on his doctor’s recommendations, he needed to sit at the register and avoid standing more than 15 minutes at a stretch.
Buc-ee’s denied the request on its own, with no interactive process. It told Witt he could split his 20-minute daily break into smaller parts and sit during those. That was not enough for him to return to work, and he was terminated.
The allegations
The EEOC tried conciliation, which failed, and filed suit in May 2026. It alleges failure to accommodate, noting that a chair was most likely a low-cost accommodation and that the employer offered no justification for refusing it or for disregarding the limitations his doctor certified. It also alleges a disability-based termination, since Witt was fired after requesting the accommodation and was unable to return without one.
The EEOC further alleges reckless indifference, based on the employer’s dismissal of the request. If a court agrees, the employer could face punitive damages.
Two similar cases
In EEOC v. Grand Hyatt, a front desk agent with chronic back pain asked for a chair. The hotel granted it, then withdrew it weeks later with no justification, no conversation, and no discussion of other accommodations. The EEOC claims this shows the same inflexibility alleged at Buc-ee’s.
The other case came out differently. A cashier with knee arthritis had used a stool for 18 years without issue. When a new manager ended the accommodation, the employer had first held real discussions and explained that leaner staffing meant every employee needed to stand and engage with customers. The employer was able to show how those changes affected the job, and the judgment was in its favor. The earlier accommodation did not lock the employer in because the business had actually changed.
What separates a win from a loss
- Patterns that lose: a blunt denial, no documented process, essential functions asserted but not proven, and no alternative offered.
- Patterns that win: an accommodation that ends only after a real business change, multiple documented meetings, essential functions that are proven, and alternatives that are actively sought and discussed.
Key takeaways for employers
- A reasonable accommodation is a legal requirement. The employer must consider it and discuss it with the employee.
- If you cannot grant the specific request, you must look at other reasonable accommodations that would let the employee perform the essential functions of the job, through a good faith conversation that starts once the request is made.
- Undue hardship requires a real and significant impact on the business, such as prohibitive cost or difficulty beyond reason. Preference alone does not qualify.
- Know the true essential functions before the process begins. A function the employee and similar colleagues have never been asked to perform is hard to defend as essential.
- A blunt dismissal of a request can support a reckless indifference claim and expose the employer to punitive damages.
- An accommodation that was granted can end, but only after a real change in business circumstances, documented meetings, and a genuine search for alternatives.
An important caveat: Buc-ee’s is pending, so everything above is the EEOC’s allegations and not a finding by a court. The similar cases come from the webinar’s summary, and the cashier case turned on its own facts. It does not mean an employer can end any long-standing accommodation by pointing to a new manager or a new staffing model. The employer won because it showed a real change and held real conversations.
Received an accommodation request you are unsure about? Reach out to your ADA coach before making a decision.