Compliance Corner: Your ADA Duties to Job Applicants

October 4, 2026
4 mins read
Author: Share

An employer cannot disqualify a job applicant because the person might need an accommodation. In EEOC v. Lori’s Gifts, a nationwide gift shop chain agreed to pay $600,000 and enter a two-year consent decree after the EEOC alleged its pre-screening questions screened out applicants with disabilities. ComPsych ADA coach Kimmy Robertson walks through the case below.

What happened

The complaint began with a woman who interviewed for a job at a Lori’s Gifts shop in Columbus, Ohio. The job description listed standing and lifting requirements. During the interview, she told the hiring manager she had an impairment that limited her ability to walk or stand for long periods. The hiring manager indicated this would not be a problem, noting that employees use a stool in the shop and that she sometimes used it herself.

After the interview, someone from the company told the candidate that standing for five hours at a time was a requirement and that she would not be hired if she could not do it. The job went to another applicant.

The EEOC filed suit in 2023. It alleged that, going back to 2018, the company used pre-screening questions, such as whether an applicant could stand for five hours or lift a certain amount of weight, and automatically disqualified anyone who answered no. The EEOC argued the questions violated the ADA because they weeded out candidates who could do the job with a reasonable accommodation, and that the requirements were neither job related nor consistent with business necessity. The stool was a good example, since it suggested constant standing was not necessary to perform the essential functions of the job.

How it resolved

The case settled in April 2026. Lori’s Gifts agreed to pay $600,000 and entered a two-year consent decree. Under the decree, the company must re-evaluate how it recruits and hires, including its pre-screening questions, to make sure they are not discriminatory. It must train all staff on disability discrimination and the ADA and report periodically to the EEOC on applicants who seek accommodations. It must also set up phone and email hotlines for employees and applicants with ADA questions or complaints, and add information to its recruiting sites on how to request an accommodation and report concerns about discrimination during the application process.

A similar case

In EEOC v. Equinox, a woman with endometriosis made it to the final interview stage and asked to push the interview back a couple of days because of a flare up. The hiring manager withdrew her candidacy and told her the company liked her but worried she would ask for time off if hired. That case settled for $48,000. Like Lori’s Gifts, it shows that an employer cannot rule out a candidate because of an accommodation she might need in the future.

Key takeaways for employers

  • The ADA applies to applicants, not just employees. An EEOC attorney said applicants with disabilities must have an equal opportunity to seek employment.
  • A qualified candidate is one who can perform the essential functions of the job with or without a reasonable accommodation.
  • Audit job descriptions regularly and be able to explain which functions are essential and why. Roles evolve, and an item on a job description is not automatically essential. Some essential functions may not be written down at all.
  • Review screening questions and questionnaires to make sure they do not target medical conditions, physical or mental, and that they relate to essential functions.
  • Make sure candidates know how to contact HR with ADA questions or to request an accommodation during the application process.
  • The Lori’s Gifts consent decree offers useful guidance for getting ahead of compliance problems instead of reacting to a lawsuit.

An important caveat: This case resolved by settlement and consent decree, so it is not precedent and the facts above are the EEOC’s allegations rather than court findings. It does show how closely the EEOC looks at hiring practices, including automated screening questions, and how long a practice can run before it draws a claim. The Lori’s Gifts questions dated back to 2018.

Have a question about accommodations during recruiting or hiring? Reach out to your ADA coach before making a decision.